Home
Up
45 Million Uninsured
Abdominal Screenings
ALS Gene Link
ALS Gene Link
Alzheimer's News
Addiction
Allergy Season
Deaf Seniors
ICU Infections
Arthritis,Bones
Blacks & Obesity
Blood Pressure News
Brushing Dentures
Cancer Headlines
Chronic Disease
Chronic Pain, Disease
Craig Screenings
Dental Health
Reliable Ovarian Test
diabetes_news
Diet
Disabilities Examined
Exercise News
Falls, Serum Link
Faith & Health
Fibromyalgia
Flu Season
Foot Care
Foot Care Myths
Get Involved
Hearing
Heart & Stroke News
HIV, AIDS on Rise
Hormone Therapy News
HRT, Incontinence
How's Your Thyroid
Incontinence Sufferers
Hip Replacement Advances
HIV, Aging Population
Incontinence Relief
Kiss, Don't Shake Hands
Lack of Action
Lung Transplants
Kidney News, Information
Less Surgery Sedation
Overactive Bladder
Liver Health News
Marrow Transplants
Medical Causes Falls
Mental Health
Million with Shingles
New Alliance
Obesity Problems
Parkinson's News
Post-Op Delerium
Psoriasis Disease Links
Problems Accumulate
Respiratory Health
Scar-Free Healing
Seeking a Cure
Seniors Health Tips
Seniors, Shingles
Spinal Injuries
Successful Therapy
Surgeon's Age
Surgery Information
Testosterone Test
Thyroid Screening
Vision and Eye Care
vitamin_use.htm
Skin and Seasons
Throat Problems
Thyroid Surgery Danger
Urinary Tract, Falls
Voice Tips
When to Call Doctor
Worst Pain?
Varicose Vein Therapy
Vertigo Treatment
Thyroid Problems
3-D Mapping

Copyright (c) 
America's Seniors/
TodaysSeniorsNetwork.com

Contact us at
America's Seniors/ 
TodaysSeniorsNetwork.com

 

Google
 

 

Web TodaysSeniorsNetwork.com

Don’t judge a surgeon by his or her age

Newswise — Researchers at the University of Michigan Health System say patients should be less concerned about the age of their surgeon and more focused on other factors the really count – like surgical volume – when choosing a surgeon.

These findings, published in the September issue of the Annals of Surgery, reveal that for some complex cardiovascular and cancer surgical procedures, surgeons older than 60 with low surgical volumes had higher patient mortality rates than their younger counterparts. However, older surgeons who continued to maintain higher surgical case loads were found to have comparable outcomes to peers ages 41 to 50.

The study also dispels the belief that younger, less experienced surgeons are more likely to have poor surgical outcomes. Instead, the researchers say young surgeons, ages 40 and under, had similar patient mortality rates to those of their more experienced peers for the eight surgical procedures studied.

“This study’s results should be very encouraging not only for patients, but also for younger and older surgeons whose operative skills may previously have been the subject of scrutiny,” says lead author Jennifer F. Waljee, M.D., M.P.H., general surgery resident in the Department of Surgery at the U-M Medical School. “The bottom line is that for most procedures the age of the surgeon is not an important predictor of operative risk for a patient. The effect of surgeon age was largely limited to those surgeons with lower procedure volumes.”

 

Previous studies that focused on primary care have suggested an inverse relationship between a surgeon’s age and his or her clinical performance. They’ve found that older physicians are less likely to know about new treatments and medications, and tend to perform poorly on recertification exams.

Based on these recent studies, Waljee and her colleagues wondered if some of the common mental and physical affects of aging might affect older surgeons’ performance in the operating room, as well.

Using data from the National Medicare Inpatient Files, the team reviewed eight major cardiovascular procedures and cancer surgical resections that were performed from 1998 to 1999 on patients between the ages 65 to 99.

For the study, surgeons were placed into three age groups: 40 years and younger, ages 41-50, and 60 years and older.

A total of 460,738 Medicare patients who underwent one of the eight surgical procedures – coronary artery bypass grafting; elective abdominal aortic aneurysm repair, aortic valve replacement, carotid endarterectomy, pancreatectomy, esophagectomy, lung resection and cystectomy – were used for this study. These procedures were chosen because they are some of the more commonly-performed procedures among Medicare patients, says Waljee.

Patient operative mortality – death before discharge or within 30 days of surgery – was reviewed for each patient. Additionally, factors such as surgeon procedure volume, hospital surgery volume and the hospital’s teaching status were evaluated.

Overall, surgeons over age 60 were found to have higher patient mortality rates when compared against the rates of surgeons ages 41-50, for three of the eight procedures: pancreatectomy, coronary artery bypass grafting, and carotid endarterectomy. Surgeon age was not related to mortality for elective abdominal aortic aneurysm repair, aortic valve replacement, exophagectomy, lung resection or cystectomy.

More surprising to researchers, however, was that the younger surgeons – those under age 40 – had comparable mortality to surgeons between the ages of 41 and 50, for all eight procedures.

“We expected to see a significant difference in patient mortality at the extremes of surgeon age, but instead found very little variation among younger and older surgeons,” says Waljee, a Robert Wood Johnson Clinical Scholar. “Based on these finding, we’d encourage patients not to focus on age when selecting a surgeon. Instead, other characteristics of the provider and practice setting, such as operative volume, are likely better predictors of patient outcome than surgeon age.”

Waljee hopes to further explore this topic through future research to determine if specific mechanisms of aging (physical and mental stamina, vision and motor skills) affect low-volume surgeons’ performance in the OR.

Along with Waljee, co-authors from the U-M Department of Surgery’s Michigan Surgical Collaborative for Outcomes Research and Evaluation (M-SCORE) are Lazar J. Greenfield, M.D.; Justin B. Dimick, M.D., M.P.H.; and John D. Birkmeyer, M.D.

The study was funded by the U-M Health System.

Home
Up
About Us
America's Seniors WebMall
Aging News
California Report
Caregiving
Community/Workplace
Grandparents
Health Care Policy
Hispanic Seniors
Medicare News
Contents/Sitemap
Prescription Drugs
Pharma Suits
Restaurant Reviews
Rural Seniors
Safety & Security
Seniors Commentary
Seniors' Entertainment
Seniors Headlines
Seniors Finances
Seniors' Issues
Seniors Relationships
Seniors Rights
Social Security News
The Virtual Family
Travel News
TSN Radio on Web
Veterans' Tribute
White House Cards
Privacy Policy
Consumer Alert
Pull Plug Heat Costs

 To Contact Us, Click here
Copyright (C) 1999-2010 TodaysSeniorsNetwork.com