Women, smoking, and Heart
Disease: Toenails tell the tale
Newswise — In a first-of-its-kind study,
research results show that toenail
nicotine levels can help predict risk of
coronary heart disease (CHD) in women.
Researchers at University of California,
San Diego, School of Medicine, in
collaboration with colleagues from
Harvard University, showed that the
higher the level of nicotine in the
toenails, the higher the risk of
coronary heart disease, no matter the
number of cigarettes smoked or level of
exposure to second hand smoke.
Study results were published in the
online edition of the American Journal
of Epidemiology, April 2008, and also
appear in the June print edition.
“Using toenail nicotine is a novel way
to objectively measure exposure to
tobacco smoke, and ultimately, to
increase our understanding of
tobacco-related illnesses,” explained
Wael Al-Delaimy, Ph.D., Department of
Family and Preventive Medicine, UC San
Diego School of Medicine.
“It has advantages over using other
biomarkers and could become a useful
test to identify high-risk individuals
in the future. This would be especially
helpful in situations where smoking
history is not available or is biased.”
Researchers analyzed toenail clippings
from 62,641 women between the ages of 36
and 61 years collected for the Nurse’s
Health Study cohort.
Between 1984 and 1998, 905 women were
diagnosed with heart disease and, on
average, those diagnosed with heart
disease had double the level of nicotine
in their toenails than women without
heart disease.
Researchers found no difference in age,
body mass index, aspirin use, or history
of high cholesterol corresponding to the
toenail nicotine levels.
Women with the highest toenail nicotine
levels were physically less active, had
a lower body mass index, drank a higher
amount of alcohol, and were more likely
to have histories of high blood
pressure, diabetes, and family history
of heart attack than women with lower
levels.
The toenails have an advantage over
other existing biomarkers of smoking
because they grow more slowly.
The levels detected in the nails
represent nicotine taken up from blood
by nails during growth.
The slow growth rates of toenails
provide a more stable estimate of
average exposure, which is most relevant
for illnesses related to tobacco smoke,
such as heart disease. Using toenail
samples in epidemiological studies is
also an attractive concept because
they’re easy to collect and store for
relatively low cost.
A limitation of this study is the
declining exposure of nonsmokers to
secondhand smoke and the decline in
active smoking nationwide.
The measured exposure in 1982 might have
misclassified exposure in later years.
“If anything, such decline in exposure
will underestimate the risk we found
between toenail nicotine levels and
heart disease,” said Al-Delaimy. “That
means the risk is possibly even higher
than reported.”
This study was funded by grant 12548
from the Flight Attendants Medical
Research Foundation.
About the Nurses’ Health Study
The Nurses’ Health Study was established
in 1976, when 121,700 registered female
nurses, 30 to 55 years old and residing
in one of 11 United States, completed a
mailed questionnaire regarding medical
history and lifestyle factors.
This information has been updated every
2 years since 1976. Cardiovascular risk
factors, such as smoking, history of
diabetes, hypertension, high
cholesterol, and dietary variables, have
been updated regularly.
In 1982, all participants were asked to
collect toenail clippings from their 10
toes and to send them in the provided
envelope.
At the beginning of the Nurses’ Health
Study participants were asked at what
age they started smoking and at what age
they stopped if they were not smoking.
If they were active smokers, they were
asked how many cigarettes they smoked
per day. The smoking status question was
repeated in each 2-year cycle including
1982. Passive smoking was recorded only
in the 1982 questionnaire.
For exposure assessment of active
smokers, those who reported being
current smokers in the 1982
questionnaires were considered as active
smokers.
Passive smokers were those who reported
exposure to tobacco smoke from the home
or work environment in the 1982
questionnaire and were never smokers in
the 1982 questionnaire.
Never exposed are those who were never
smokers up to the 1982 questionnaire and
reported not being exposed to tobacco
smoke from others in 1982.
Past smokers are those who reported
being smokers previously but were not
active smokers in 1982.
About UC San Diego Department of Family
and Preventive Medicine
The UC San Diego Department of Family
and Preventive Medicine ranks first
nationally among peer departments in
federal research dollars granted.
It is composed of a unique blend of
interdisciplinary researchers and
clinicians dedicated to conducting
ground-breaking research that influences
public policy and conquers disease.
The department also offers a broad-based
curriculum to UCSD undergraduates,
medical students, residents, and
physicians across the country, and
provides health education and clinical
care to the underserved community.